11.2.2 Customer value dimensions
In the context of supply chain management we need to look more specifically at what we understand by value and how the management of services can be configured to generate value to the maximum level possible. Customer service is undoubtedly one of the major elements which determine the value of a product. It is therefore necessary to look at the customer service dimensions. The widely accepted trend is to view customer service in the marketing context under three different headings (Christopher 1997):
- pre transaction elements
- transaction elements
- post transaction elements
These three elements are further expanded below to identify the relevant customer service dimensions in the context of supply chain and logistics management (Christopher 1997).
Pre transaction elements |
|
Written customer service policy: |
documented and well articulated policy |
Accessibility: |
easy to reach and easy to communicate |
Organisational culture: |
management focus on customer service and organisational structure |
System flexibility: |
adaptability to meet customer requirement |
Transaction elements |
|
Order cycle time: |
elapsed time between order and delivery |
Inventory availability: |
percentage of demand met from stock in hand |
Order fill rate: |
proportion of order filled within the stated lead time |
Order status information: |
query response time and exception advise |
Post- transaction elements |
|
Availability of spares: |
in stock level of service parts |
Warranty and product tracing: |
warranty handling and product tracing capability |
Customer complaint handling: |
dealing with complaints and returns |
This way customer service can be viewed as an important front end element for value creation. However, customer service should not, of itself, be equated with 'value' in this context.
In the context of supply chain management, the value concept has to extend to all channel members in order to create an winning supply chain. In the previous chapter we saw examples of lean and agile supply chains and the concept of leagile supply chains. If you refer to that chapter you will notice that the concept of lean supply chains is based on removal of wastes from the system. Taking the example of Toyota , we see that this can result in a product which is of high quality and which can be provided at a minimum cost to the consumer. If you look at the value dimensions of this approach, these are the cost and quality of the product. In contrast, BMW or Rover has adopted a different 'value' creation approach by offering their customers customised cars. The value here is the personal satisfaction of owning an unique and personalised car, albeit at a higher price. These examples demonstrate how the 'value' of a product is the result of a unique combination of many different attributes.
Table 11.1 Value proposition of lean and agile automotive supply chains
Value proposition: |
|
Toyota |
BMW/Rover |
Quality |
Personal design |
Cost |
Cost |
Customer service |
Quality |
|
Customer service |
Readily available stock |
Must wait for delivery |
We know how these two different supply chain types require implementation of different system wide strategies to generate value for their particular markets and particular market segments. This is an example of the critical relationship between customer value and supply chain systems.
In your text
Read Section 10.2 .
The above section deals with the concept of dimensions of customer value in a generalised way and the contents essentially expand our foregoing discussion. You will notice that the various dimensions mentioned in the text, including brand, product availability, choice of design, price and value-added service all have implications on supply chain design and management strategies.