2.1.2 Selection
Once you have a list of job applicants it is necessary to select the best candidate for the job. The selection process can be difficult because it requires an understanding of what the job involves and what is required of a person to adequately perform the job. A brief step-by-step guide for selection is discussed below:
Identify any relevant legislation and organisational policy
Selection is governed by legislation such as equal opportunity, anti-discrimination and occupational health and safety laws. It is important to be aware of how these laws affect the way that you choose appropriate employees. Most larger organisations and efficient smaller companies have Human Resource manuals that guide selection, recruitment and induction of employees. Be sure to access these documents early in the process if they do exist.
Obtain a job description
The job description tells you what an employee is required to do in order to perform adequately in a certain position. A detailed description of the daily activities that are required in a position forms the basis for developing the selection criteria, discussed in the next step.
Establish selection criteria
The job description will help you to work out a list of the qualities an employee will need to demonstrate in order to be effective. For example, if the job description establishes the competencies required by the employee other qualities required for the workplace may also be detailed. The selection criteria should reflect all the core aspects required to work in the given situation. These descriptions may be developed together with the supervisor of the new employee, their colleagues and even potential subordinates.
Short list job applications
Job vacancies often receive more applications than an organisation can handle. Many organisations ask applicants to send in a resume or job application in order to cut out those applications that are unlikely to be successful.
Conduct an interview
The selection criteria are used to develop a list of questions that are asked at an interview. The answers to each question are rated according to how well they meet the criteria. It is essential to have more than one person interviewing in order to overcome any potential personal bias of a single interviewer and to minimise legal risk.
Short list and check references
Once all applicants have been interviewed their interview scores are tallied and the best applicants are short-listed. The next step is to contact the remaining applicants' references and check their previous work history.
Choose the best candidate and follow-up
The final step is to choose the one candidate who best fits the selection criteria and inform them of the decision. It is often useful to advise the successful candidate of the decision before informing the unsuccessful candidates. This is because some candidates may decide to not take up the position and you will need to offer the job to the next most suitable candidate. Follow-up is an important aspect to the selection and recruitment process. Applicants, especially unsuccessful ones, may seek feedback to improve their future chances of successfully navigating a selection process. Others may be dissatisfied and seek to pursue a grievance procedure. In both cases procedures should be in place and follow any existing documentation provided by the organisation for such practices.
Dangers of a poor selection/recruitment process include:
- Employee is not capable of doing the job
- Employee is not qualified to undertake the role required
- Employee is incompatible with existing employees or the team
- Costs associated with turnover of staff through incorrect selection, retraining, etc.
- Cost to the department of ineffective team member
- Overall failure to contribute to capacity of the team or organisation